Skip to main content

Speaking Frankly

One of my favorite architects if Frank Lloyd Wright. It's a fairly common condition for students of American architecture - the man is not only a legendary figure, his work stood the test of time (literally and figuratively) and has gone on to form many of the trends we still live with to this day. It is the timelessness of his innovation that speaks to me, and while I find his work often to be brooding and cluttered, I appreciate very much the revolution he helped inform/foment in the way we view living spaces.

It's important to understand the historical context of his design work. He was born in 1867 but didn't really start his work until he was in his thirties. He was influenced in his early years by many sources - he worked with some of Chicago's great and prosperous architects, especially with Louis Sullivan, who designed structures that were intentionally organic in both design and form. He experienced a kind of revulsion from the Victorian designs of the time, looking to open spaces up, emphasizing the horizontality of his buildings, and removing much of the extraneous frippery and gingerbread. He was also heavily influenced by Asian architecture and art, coming to appreciate the beauty in natural forms and the elegance of simple, clear lines, again emphasizing the horizontality of the structure. His buildings were not monuments placed upon the earth; rather, his work felt both connected to the earth and as if they'd sprung out of the skin of the earth itself. And he did it at least 30 years before anyone else, which is what makes it so incredible.

This morning I read this:

http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887323372504578469410621274292

Owning an older home is almost always fraught with issues that more recent home owners do not have to concern themselves with. From foundation issues, to roof issues, to everything in between, the standards of construction, building, and repair have changed over the decades, and while standardization makes things easy to install and repair for modern structures, it also means that much of the older stuff is outmoded.

As an example, I learned in my graduate classes in Historical Preservation that the Utah State Capital had an issue with replacing some of the tile in the floor. It's this lovely hexagonal tile, and when the building was made in the 20s, the tile was something like 3/8" thick. Today, the standard is probably something like 1/4", or maybe even 3/16"... which means that there would have been a difference in the thickness of the new vs. the older tiles. This is unacceptable, of course, but what to do? Do you rip out all of the existing tile to get a uniform thickness? If that would even be possible, it probably would be terribly expensive. Besides, such a solution wouldn't remain true to the historicity of the floor... So they had a manufacturer create some historically accurate 3/8" thick tiles to install in the building. I've been up there since, and it's virtually impossible to see where the new tile is placed (you'd probably have to have an old photograph of the cracked old tile...)

So living in an older home can be a challenge, but it comes with rewards. You're holding on to a piece of history. You're helping to inform future decisions in home building, while at the same time preserving a piece of the character of a neighborhood. And you're conserving resources that have already been expended in the creation of the home in the first place, some of which will never be able to be replaced.

You also get to live in a cool old house, which is an intangible, but still very real benefit.

I may never be able to afford a FLW home. But I still appreciate the beauty and elegance of these places, the simplicity and craftsmanship of the spaces, and those who sacrifice to keep them lovely and alive.

Comments

Lara Neves said…
Lately I've been frustrated with some of the issues presented to us by our 100+ year home. I love it for the most part, but fixes that shouldn't cost much are costing a tremendous amount because they are outdated and getting the parts is expensive! Thanks for giving me a better perspective today as I'm going to be shelling out 500 dollars to get the faucet in our clawfoot tub/shower replaced--and that's just for the faucet, not the labor!
Bill Cobabe said…
That's awesome, Lara! We lived in a rented home that was 100 years old while we were in Oregon. It was very cool (not to mention affordable) and the owners had taken some time to update the place, which meant that we didn't have to worry about things breaking (like what you've mentioned). It certainly had it's quirks, though, including no door on the master bathroom (?), narrow steps that had 9" risers (the standard is more like 7 1/2" or 8") and little things like that. I loved it, but the rest of the fam hated it. So when we moved here to Utah, I bought a home that was built in the past 10 years. It's nice and comfortable, efficient and easy, but also terribly boring.

Best of luck with the tub. :) I come from generations of plumbers, so I know the joys of dealing with plumbing. Fortunately I am able to do most of my own stuff myself...
lillysmum said…
I owned a 100+ year old house for 10 years and I LOVED it, despite it's many and sundry issues. I now live in a modern apartment, which is nice, but I miss my out of level wood floors and my enormous claw foot tub. And my amazing windows and doors.

Popular posts from this blog

The Other Art

I'm not sure we appreciate photography as much as we do other art forms. Part of this comes from the reality that surrounds and permeates a photograph - it's very, very real, and the photographer strives for clarity and crispness in the representations. Perhaps this is why black and white images continue to be relevant - they strip away extraneous information (color) and leave us with something that is at once familiar and also non-existent - for nothing exists in black and white. Nothing. I also think that pictures are becoming too common-place... Everyone has a camera in their pocket, and while that's a very democratic thing (everyone can express themselves in a picture easily and readily, and can find an audience for these images, which are casually taken and casually viewed, and perhaps just as casually forgotten) I think that we embrace that casual attitude, and it spills over to all aspects of the media, making it impotent. So I read this article this morning: h...

Lucky!

So Tomorrow is Amie's birthday. The 12 th is Andy's. The 14 th is Alex's. And the 26 th is mom's. Happy birthday everyone. I recently found that a member of our ward has been diagnosed with pancreatic cancer. Pancreatic cancer has a survivability rate of less than 5% and you never, ever kick it, even if you live. Once diagnosed, people are expected to live about six months. My wife and I were talking about this wonderful woman. There are very few (too few) people in this world who shine. Literally. This sister shines with a light that is perceptible and discernible . The world will literally be a darker place without her in it. Life is short, folks. Too short for hard feelings, too short for pain and misunderstanding. I love you all so much. Sorry this one is such a downer... I don't mean to be lugubrious on your birthdays... I consider myself lucky to be your brother. You have and continue to bless me and my family in many ways, for which I will be eternally gra...

Excommunication

My heart is heavy this morning. I read that Kate Kelly and others are being brought up on Church disciplinary action. For those who are unfamiliar with the process/proceedings of LDS Church discipline, it can be a bit mystifying. There are several levels of censure that the Church may impose. These range from a simple removal of some privileges for a short period of time to the most severe action - excommunication. When one is excommunicated, the person's membership in the Church is terminated. It is a very extreme measure, and for the faithful it can be a very difficult thing to consider. What people don't understand - what is nearly impossible for someone outside the proceedings to understand - is the amount of love felt. It's discipline. It's intended to be harsh (at times). And it's intended to be unpleasant. But it is done with love and care for the person. Since excommunication is such an extreme measure, it is really only very rarely applied. There are ...